Hi!
I’m creating this thread to gather rulings that specifically contradict the rulebook. Please add your contributions, though I imagine this thread will be able to remain quite short.
On page 18: Active Player Decides, the rulebook states:
Any effect requiring a decision always refers to the active player. […] In the unusual event that an event that an effect specifically asks an opponent to make a decision on your turn, instead nothing happens.
There was a ruling that contradicts this here: Rules Questions thread - #3107 by sharpobject
Basically, it feels unnatural for things like Bamstamper Lizzo and Cursed Ghoul to give their arrives: x triggers to the active player if returned from play by Prynn’s maxband interaction ending.
So, I propose the following substitution for the first and last sentences of the Active Player Decides rule:
In general, effects requiring a decision refers to the active player. […] However, any trigger requiring a decision (ie. Vandy Anadrose’s maxband) on a card not controlled by the active player will be ignored unless stated otherwise. Also, In the unusual event that an event that an effect specifically asks an opponent to make a decision on your turn, instead nothing happens.