Orange County, CA players?

[ARMed_PIrate]

These were the best reviews from the Sleeve thread in terms of fitting the cards and fitting in official binders:

@Drakona

I went with these: (200) Ultra-Pro Black Deck Protector Sleeves 2-Packs - Standard Magic the Gathering size Amazon.com

They fit very nicely, both around the cards and in the binders. They don’t stick, at least not that I’ve noticed, and the opaque backs solve my worn card / shuffling fairness issue, though they do present a problem where the double sided cards are concerned. The backs are a nice matte, non-sticky texture that shuffles well, and the fronts are nice and clear. They do have an unnecessary-seeming little silver sticker on the bottom, but it luckily doesn’t seem to block anything important.

I would have to say these are the best sleeves I’ve ever used! (They are the only sleeves I’ve ever used. But they do seem to get the job done.)

If these are the same size as the ones you linked, then those should do well.

@Muse

I’m currently using old glossy dragon shield white sleeves. I can barely see the back of then codex card which allows me to adjust the cards so they are all right side up (I’m picky like that). No issues with the codex binders at all (2 cards in each pocket). Barely any sticking for me, but my home is AC’ed. However, even with the thick dragon shields, the cards feel extremely thin. I may end up double sleeving codex since these are the thinnest cards I own. My print and play games are actually thicker when sleeved.

If we’re thinking of getting sleeves as prize support, we should talk to Dice House this weekend and see what it would cost to get the same sleeves through them. They likely get shipping discounts through distributors, or might be more willing to buy in bulk if they’re confident they’ll eventually sell the excess to Magic players.