OK, here are some examples for dwarddd’s Option 2.1, following on from the examples I gave for Option 2.
Pick bad P1, then match fairly to P2:
| P1 | P2 |
|---|---|
| [Feral]/Future/Past | [Present]/Feral/Strength |
| [Future]/Law/Truth | [Discipline]/Balance/Bashing |
| [Feral]/Law/Ninjitsu | [Past/Present]/Balance |
| [Balance/Feral]/Peace | PPA |
| [Future/Present]/Disease | [Blood]/Disease/Present |
| [Future]/Fire/Truth | [Strength]/Bashing/Necromancy |
| [Past]/Fire/Truth | [Blood]/Bashing/Necromancy |
| [Future/Present]/Truth | [Strength]/Necromancy/Past |
| [Peace]/Feral/Future | [Finesse]/Anarchy/Disease |
| [Past]/Disease/Truth | [Law]/Anarchy/Fire |
Pick bad P2, then match fairly to P1:
| P1 | P2 |
|---|---|
| [Present]/Feral/Fire | [Law]/Ninjitsu/Present |
| [Peace]/Disease/Finesse | [Discipline]/Law/Present |
| [Peace]/Demonology/Future | [Feral]/Finesse/Past |
| [Balance/Growth]/Bashing | [Fire]/Discipline/Present |
| [Feral]/Law/Truth | [Discipline]/Demonology/Present |
| [Fire]/Necromancy/Strength | [Discipline]/Growth/Present |
| [Past]/Growth/Peace | [Discipline]/Necromancy/Past |
| [Truth]/Fire/Strength | [Discipline]/Future/Present |
| [Anarchy]/Bashing/Necromancy | [Strength]/Bashing/Disease |
| [Present]/Balance/Necromancy | [Peace]/Discipline/Fire |
The likes of PPA turning up as suggested opponents makes me a little uneasy here, although I haven’t given much thought to how that matchup would work out.
Thoughts on the given example lists?