It’s not straightforward to encode either way, no. The issue with applying brute-force spaghetti code is the same that it usually is with spaghetti code: it’s very difficult to work out whether it’s doing the right thing, or how to fix it if it isn’t. I don’t use them, but my understanding is that, especially for non-standard tasks, LLMs are very good at producing spaghetti code at a large scale, which makes this issue worse.
Yes, having checks / automated testing would help with this, whether you’re using an LLM or not. I’ve mentioned writing unit tests for the edge cases as a pipe dream before, for exactly this reason. That’s still time-consuming, though, especially if you allow multicolour.
If you want to know what his opinion on that is, you can ask him directly via the official Discord server or use the contact info on the Sirlin Games website. He has allowed some people to do fan digitization projects before, with some ground rules in place like it must be free and must be clear that Sirlin Games is the rights owner, however I don’t know whether he’s answered about using generative AI for creating one before since all similar previous projects were coded by hand. Either way though, legally a guess as to what his opinion would be is worthless, so if this is something you actually want to do rather than just a thought experiment, you would need to ask him.
Sirlin himself has vehemently denied every using AI for any of his projects, despite [censored censored] upcoming [censored censored censored] in my opinion.
oh, thx for the info, although I cant read half of the post just to be clear: i’m not a big fan of the technology either. i fear that the effects on society and environment will be devastating. and i think it’s crazy to throw that much money and resources into the development of genAI. but if there is one use case for the technology, I see it in coding/software development and related fields. i recently used genAI to finally ditch Windows and switch to CachyOS for good - no way I’ll ever go back… so it empowered me in this case to cut the ties to big tech. i felt like a centaur (not like a reverse centaur - see the new book by cory doctorow for further explanation of the reference ).