That’s not correct. I can see why you might think that, since the official rulebook doesn’t explicitly state how many heroes each player should use for those modes, but three heroes is definitely the intended number for every mode. To be certain, I just asked @sharpobject (the official rules keeper for Codex) on Discord, and he confirmed that three heroes is the intended way to play every mode.
As for the rest, it looks like pretty much everything you’re doing different from my suggestions is probably even better than what I’d suggested. Do you want me to keep going with this? I’ve got most of the next two pages written up, but if you’re likely to change the layout of some pages, parts of it might not even be relevant anymore.
Edit: Since I’ve finished them, I’ll go ahead and post the suggestions I have for the next two pages. Keep in mind that most of this was written before you replied to my previous suggestions, so they didn’t really factor into what I wrote for these.
Here There Be Further Ramblings
This looks like a good place to make it clear that using one hero should only be done when still learning the game. There’s quite a bit of blank space here, so something like the following could work:
Each player should choose three heroes and set up their playmat as shown. If this is your first game, you might want to start with each player only using one hero so that there’s fewer cards to worry about.
You have to choose at this point whether to show the setup for a three hero game or a one hero game. If the former (which I’d recommend), you’ll need to change the graphic to show three heroes. I’d suggest using either three heroes of the same color or two and a neutral hero, since a new player should probably steer clear of mixing colors until they’ve played monocolor a few times. You may also want to change the text box to be plural, like so:
Hero Cards: Place on the hero slots in your command zone
I’d change the wording from “choose a 1st player” to “choose who goes first.” Similarly, “the 1st player” and “the 2nd player” seem a bit clunky compared to “player 1” and “player 2.” Although, now that I think about it, there’s an opportunity to slip in the way starting workers are handled in free-for-all without making it look unnatural to someone who thinks it’s just a two player game:
Decide who goes first. If you’re player 1, place this card in your Workers zone with the x4 side up. Otherwise, place the x5 side up. (This shows how many workers you start with.)
More importantly, why is the worker card shown sideways on the graphic? This happens again later in the manual, so it’s clearly not just an oversight, but I have no clue why it’s like that. There’s plenty of room on the actual playmats for the worker cards to be oriented vertically, and that’s how it’s shown in the official manual as well.
This is being written with the assumption that players have bought either the Core Set or the Deluxe Set, right? That means they should already have the HP dial, so the setup should probably just use that instead of suggesting alternatives immediately. Those who want to use something else will do so without the manual’s permission.
Set the HP dials to 20 HP for each player.
I think you should call them “starting cards” instead of “basic cards.” That’s what the official manual uses, and the term “basic” has its own connotations. Some of the cards in the starting decks are more complicated than some Tech II cards!
**Starting Deck: Find the 10 starting cards that match the color of one of your heroes. Shuffle these cards face-down to form your deck.
Again, since the reader should have the Core or Deluxe set, that means they already have at least two binders. There’s no need to confuse them by implying that a stack of cards could work as well as the binder they already have.
Find the 24 cards that match the specialization (or “spec” for short) of each of your heroes. Don’t shuffle these cards—put them in a binder to make your codex (see page 12 for how to arrange the cards).
Red Help Box (not sure what else to call this)
This just needs some rephrasing and editing:
If you use Jaina, the Fire hero, put the 24 cards from the Fire spec into your codex. You can also choose to use the Red starter deck.
Starting cards have a dot in the upper-left corner and the name of their color at the bottom (like Red).
Non-starting cards have no corner dot and instead of a color they have their spec’s name (like Fire).
Misc. Thoughts for Page 3
The label for the deck and discard is being covered up by the graphic for the deck. Not sure how I missed that until now, but once you notice that it’s pretty distracting…
As discussed on page 2, this is mislabeled. It should be “Spec Contents” instead. I’d also rephrase the sentence at the top to say:
Each hero’s spec has 2 copies each of 12 cards:
That gets rid of the last bullet point and makes it a bit less awkward.
First Game Suggestions
I think this would be better positioned left of Codex Spec Contents so that readers see it sooner. That way, they’ll already know that they should only use one spec for their first game before seeing the breakdown of what’s in a spec.
This may be too long, but here’s my ideal version of this box’s contents:
For your first game, you should only use one hero and the cards in their spec instead of three.
If you have the Deluxe Set, each player should pick one of the two Neutral Heroes (Troq Bashar and River Montoya) for a simplified game meant for new players.
With the Core Set, you can use Calamandra Moss (Feral) and Jaina Stormborne (Fire) as substitutes for Troq and River.
Deluxe Variant: Maps
Maybe add a bit saying that you should only use them after you’re already familiar with Codex?
This should be renamed to something like “Game Modes.” The word variant, at least to me, gives the impression that there is One True Way to play the game and everything listed as a variant isn’t the “real” game. Two-player, 2v2 team battles, and free-for-all with up to 5 players are all valid ways to play the game, and should be treated as such. If anything, playing with only one hero per player is the weird variant.
Codex can support 2-5 players. The full rules for the different modes of play start on page 12.
Tournament Game (3v3)
Change the heading to something like “One-on-One” and drop “3v3” entirely. I know some people use “3v3” to refer to having three heroes on each side, but that breaks the existing gaming convention that the “?v?” format refers to the number of players on each side. That said, an idea I had to replace it is to have silhouettes of the number of players for each mode. The best I can do on the forums is use the built-in emoji, but you can use whatever you like. Alternatively, if you don’t like the idea of using icons you can do something else, but I think having the maximum number of players for each mode easily visible next to the mode’s name would be helpful.
The first sentence needs rephrased to make it clearer that this is the mode players are intended to play most.
Adding the option for new players to use only one hero in parentheses should make it clear that the one hero mode is a variant of the normal three hero game.
The “main hero” thing doesn’t actually affect gameplay beyond the choice of starting deck, so I would reword that section to remove it entirely.
One-on-One ( VS )
This is the standard way to play Codex, designed to be balanced for years of tournament play.
- Both players choose 3 heroes and place them in their command zone (new players may want to start with just 1 hero).
- Choose a starting deck that matches the color of one of your heroes. For example, if you are using Jaina, Calamandra and Grave as your heroes, you could choose the Red, Green, or White starting deck.
- Add the cards from each of your heroes’ specs to your codex for a total of 72 cards (or 24 if you only use one hero).
Two-Headed Dragon (2-player teams)
Putting the stuff about the base first makes sure the players know right away how the goal of the game differs from the 1v1 mode.
Instead of talking about the nitty-gritty details of workers, emphasize the teamwork aspect.
Two-Headed Dragon ( VS )
This mode is for a battle between two teams, each of which has two players.
- Each team shares a single base with 30 HP. One team wins by destroying the other team’s base.
- Each player gets their own playmat, heroes, starting deck, codex, and workers, and they each draw their own hand of cards.
- Both players on a team take their turns at the same time, and can work together to combine cards in ways a single player never could!
Free-for-all (3-5 players)
I added some stuff from the official manual that talks about how you might want to team up with people temporarily, since that’s a big part of what makes this free-for-all mode different from those in other games (since those ones have player elimination, those who are in the running for the lead are likely to gang up and eliminate weaker players).
Speaking of which, I basically rewrote all of the bullets in this section from scratch to emphasize what makes this free-for-all mode different both from the other modes of Codex and from other free-for-all modes. The existing bullet points seemed too stuck on the details of play instead of painting a picture of the mode as a whole.
Free-for-all ( VS VS VS VS )
This mode is for 3-5 players to play against each other. There are no teams, and only one player can win, but you’ll need to make temporary alliances at some points during the game.
- Once any player’s base is destroyed, the player whose base has the most remaining HP wins (there’s no player elimination).
- You can repair your base at a cost of 3 gold per 1 HP.
- If an opponent’s unit dies during your turn, you get a 1 gold bounty for its death (up to 3 gold per turn).
- You can have your units patrol in other players’ Patrol Zones to protect them from losing before you can take the lead.